New Jersey’s high court ruled this summer that damage from a subcontractor’s faulty workmanship is covered under the general contractor’s commercial general liability policy.
The ruling stems from a New Jersey lawsuit charging that the subcontractor that built a condominium complex failed to properly install roofs, gutters, windows, doors, and other components, which later led to serious water-related damage.
The condo owners sued and lost. A trial judge ruled in favor of the insurers, noting that CGL policies don’t cover consequential damages from defective workmanship.
The Appellate Division of the state Supreme Court reversed that ruling, noting that the damage resulting from the subcontractor’s shoddy work was property damage caused by an “accidental occurrence.” The ruling defined it as unintended “continuous or repeated exposure to substantially the same general harmful conditions.” It can’t reasonably be argued that the subcontractors expected or intended for their faulty workmanship to cause property damage, the panel said.
The state Supreme Court affirmed the appellate ruling, adding that the term “accident,” as used in the policies, includes unintended and unexpected harm caused by negligent conduct.
With its decision, the New Jersey supreme court joined two dozen other state high courts that have agreed on this issue.
Add new comment
Related Stories
Contractor Facing Lawsuit in ‘Major Case’ by Ohio Attorney General
An Ohio custom builder and remodeler faces a lawsuit after alleged losses exceeding $1 million
Learn from the Best in Home Improvement and Remodeling
This year’s Pinnacle Experience aims to help remodelers stay ahead of their competitors by featuring captivating keynote speakers and subject matter experts, collaborative roundtable discussions, and networking with proven players from across the country.
Registration Open for The Pinnacle Experience 2024
Register today for The Pinnacle Experience 2024 in Baltimore from June 26-28. Join the best and brightest in home improvement and remodeling for insight, advice, and relationship-building that will help you take your business to new heights.
Marvin Releases Switchable Privacy Glass Window
The privacy glass windows can be purchased from Marvin's Direct Glaze windows
Gas Ban in New Construction Considered by Chicago
The mayor-backed ordinance would impact all new construction
Working Toward Affordable, Resilient Homes
A new natural disaster protection act from NAHB aims to support hazard mitigation projects
The Remodeling Market Could Turn in Q4, Says Harvard
Repair and remodeling spending could see an uptick at the end of the year
Seattle Contractor Finds Grenade During Remodel
Polar Bear Construction Owner Vadim Kharkhavyy and the owner were equally shocked
New Independent Contractor Rule Faces Lawsuit
The Department of Labor submitted new criterion to judge when classifying workers
New Insulation Innovation Reshapes Our Thinking of Refrigeration
Whirlpool Corporation's latest innovation allows refrigerators to do more and be more